• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Get Cooking!

Recipes, Kitchen Gadgets, Cookbook Reviews, Gluten Free Recipes...

  • Home
    • Contact
    • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Sitemap
    • Store
  • Reviews
    • Cookware Reviews
    • Food Reviews
      • Gluten Free Food Reviews
      • Health Food Reviews
    • Bakeware
    • Candy Reviews
    • Coffee Reviews
      • Aerobie AeroPress Coffee and Espresso Maker
      • Coffee Makers & Grinders
    • Cookbook Reviews
      • Cooking Magazines
    • Kitchen Gadgets
    • Small Kitchen Appliances
  • Gifts & Collectibles
    • Candy Bowls
    • Christmas Shopping
    • Coffee Mugs
    • Canister Sets
    • Cookie Cutters
    • Gifts for Coffee Lovers
    • Gifts for Tea Lovers
    • Owls in the Kitchen
    • Pig Collectors
  • Recipe Index
  • How to Be a Better Cook
    • Baked Sweet Potatoes in the Oven
    • Cooking Videos
    • Perfect Baked Potatoes in Your Oven
You are here: Home / Recipes / Amish Cooking / Perfect Amish Pumpkin Pie Recipe

Perfect Amish Pumpkin Pie Recipe

November 17, 2012 By Joi Sigers

I may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This costs you absolutely no extra money (of course), it simply allows me to maintain the lifestyle my cats are accustomed to!

The following pumpkin pie recipe is from one of my favorite (and most used) cookbooks – Cooking With the Horse & Buggy People. Is that a great title or what?  Honestly, I adore this spiral bound collection of Amish recipes. It’s available on Amazon for next to nothing and, believe me, you’ll use it throughout the year MANY, MANY times!
Amish Cookbook

Pumpkin Pie


4 eggs, sparated
1 cup white sugar
1 cup brown sugar
2 cups pumpkin
2 tsp pumpkin pie spice
4 Tbs flour
Pinch of salt
2 tsp vanilla
5 Cups milk (pet milk), heated
2 Pie Shells

Beat egg whites and set aside. Beat egg yolks and brown sugar together until light in color. Add the white sugar, followed by the rest of the ingredients. Fold in egg whites last.

Bake at 425 degrees until brown, then at 325 degrees for 45 minutes or done.

Yield: 2 pies

Click through the link above or the image for more information about the Amish cookbook – over 600 Amish recipes!

Filed Under: Amish Cooking, Best Cookbook Recipes, Pies and Pastries, Thanksgiving Recipes

Previous Post: « Soup’s On! At Least it Will Be with These Recipes
Next Post: Christmas Cookbook You Have to Order Today! »

Primary Sidebar

Welcome to the Get Cooking Food Blog

My name is Joi (“Joy”) and Get Cooking is where I celebrate some of my greatest passions: Recipes, kitchen gadgets, gluten free food reviews, gluten free recipes, pig collectibles, chocolate, cookbooks, and coffee.

Lots of coffee…

  • Email
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter

What’s New on the Food Blog?

  • T-Fal Signature Nonstick 12 Piece Cookware Set
  • Easy Southern Fried Green Tomatoes: Perfect Alone or On Burgers or BLTs
  • Summer Kitchen Towels, for that Summer State of Mind!
  • Easy Dill Tartar Sauce: An Easy Tartar Sauce Recipe That Happens to Be One of the Best
  • Melamine Dinnerware Set (These Dishes are to DIE FOR!)
  • Great New Obsession: Silicone Loaf Pans!
  • An INGENIOUS Way to Prepare and Eat Chicken: Where Has this Method Been all My Life?!
  • Fellow Purple Fanatics, You’re Going to LOVE These Dishes

Gluten-Free Recipes

A Wonderful Gluten-Free and Vegetarian Cookbook: Whole Bowls by Allison Day

Pumpkin Stuffed Green Lentil Cannelloni

Gluten-Free Pumpkin Stuffed Green Lentil Cannelloni

Gluten-Free Lasagna with Explore Cuisine Green Lentil Lasagna Noodles

Easy Gluten-Free Lasagna with Explore Cuisine Green Lentil (No Boil!) Noodles

Tostadas with Refried Beans and Tomatoes

Fast & Easy Summer Meal: Meatless Tostadas

Gluten-Free White Chocolate and Pecan Cookies

Gluten Free Cranberry Pecan Cookies

Gluten Free Pecan Sandies

Gluten Free Pecan Sandies Recipe

Footer

T-fal… As Good as Good Gets

The T-Fal Cookware Set (Amazon link), above, is available in several gorgeous colors.

Subscribe to Get Cooking

Fill in the form below to receive updates through e-mail whenever something new has been added to the food blog.



Powered by FeedBlitz

  • Email
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Contact me through e-mail at joisigers@aim.com and/or connect with me through social media (see above)!

I do not claim to have taken all of the photographs on this website. I did not take any of the “product” or “affiliate” merchandise photos, nor do I claim to own them. If you are a photographer that sees something you want removed, simply e-mail me!</font size>

Copyright © 2021 Get Cooking Food Blog   xml sitemap   Privacy Policy   Color Me Gluten Free!